IFPTE Local 777 provided bargaining proposals today to management at Chicago District, Pittsburgh District, and South Pacific Division—kicking off three parallel negotiations.
As with all collective bargaining in the Federal sector, management cannot legally implement these changes until bargaining is complete, with an agreement ratified by the union members and approved by DoD.
In this case, our management sent identical notices to each of our Chapters, which said that they intended—starting with the short performance cycle that ended September 30, 2026—to implement a cap on the number of Outstanding (level 5) ratings; and a “calibration” process to ensure there aren’t “inflated” ratings in work units.
The Local started with an argument that the DoD guidance on this change says that “This guidance does not apply to… Bargaining unit employees covered by an active collective bargaining agreement (CBA) that currently contains provisions that prevent implementation of all or specific parts of the revised performance management regulations, until such time as the agreement expires and those provisions can be brought into compliance.” (Emphasis added.)
Management didn’t read that language the same way we did… which didn’t surprise us. We planned for this and a committee across Chapters brainstormed proposal language. We also asked all three HR reps a list of 12 questions to help us understand how they planned to carry this out. None of them answered—Surely not because they don’t know. Nevertheless, we provided our proposals to make sure we don’t lose the chance to bargain to agreement over this important change.
Proposal 1:
The rating population for the purposes of the Standard Distribution of Ratings (SDR) limit and Calibration of Outstanding ratings for Chicago District/Pittsburgh District/South Pacific Division (LRC/LRP/SPD) Bargaining Unit Employees (BUE) shall consist of the entire Bargaining Unit (BU) as a single group; and this group may not include non-BUEs.
This is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the USACE IG Memo, para. 6(a) and Army IG Memo, Att. 1, para. 7.b.; and a §7106(b)(3) appropriate arrangement for adversely affected employees—to ensure that BUEs receive a fair proportion of the SDR consistent with Art. 1 § 3 of the CBA.
Proposal 2:
The Union Vice-President (or designee) shall be included as an observer of the calibration for the LRC/LRP/SPD BUE rating population.
This is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW IG Memo, Att. 1, para. 5.c., which explicitly states that panels are allowed; and because it is an observer role only and the population being calibrated is limited to BUEs, it does not interfere with Management’s rights.
Proposal 3:
The SDR limit for Outstanding ratings of the LRC/LRP/SPD BU rating population shall be the greater of 48% or the rolling five-year average of Outstanding ratings assigned to LRC/LRP/SPD BUEs.
The OPM regulation at 5 CFR 430.208(c) permits, but does not require, an SDR. Accordingly, the Union’s proposals must only be consistent with the Agency’s regulations to the extent those regulations have a compelling need. We assert that is not the case here. This proposal is a §7106(b)(3) appropriate arrangement for adversely affected employees—to ensure that employees’ opportunity to achieve an Outstanding rating is not constrained by an arbitrary threshold, but rather is tied to historic performance of the relevant employees.
Proposal 4:
All final decisions pertaining to calibration disagreements regarding any LRC/LRP/SPD BUE shall be documented in writing.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the final sentence of the USACE IG Memo, para. 6(b).
Proposal 5:
No calibration factor shall be utilized in a rating cycle for LRC/LRP/SPD BUEs unless it was (1) disclosed to affected BUEs at the initial performance plan meeting of that rating cycle, and (2) BUEs were given opportunity to participate in the establishment of the factor.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the USACE IG Memo, para. 6(c), consistent with 5 U.S.C. § 4302(a)(2) and DoDI 1400.25 v. 430, para. 4.3.c. Additionally, the OPM regulation at 5 CFR 430.208(c) permits, but does not require, calibration. Accordingly, the Union’s proposals must only be consistent with the Agency’s regulations to the extent those regulations have a compelling need. We assert that is not the case here.
Proposal 6:
No calibration decision regarding any LRC/LRP/SPD BUE shall rely upon any evidence of mission outcomes, customer feedback, or project results unless the affected BUE was provided the evidence at least three weeks prior to the BUE’s suspense for inputting the final self-assessment.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW IG Memo, fifth para., second bullet. Additionally, the OPM regulation at 5 CFR 430.208(c) permits, but does not require, calibration. Accordingly, the Union’s proposals must only be consistent with the Agency’s regulations to the extent those regulations have a compelling need. We assert that is not the case here.
Proposal 7:
Critical elements for LRC/LRP/SPD BUEs that are “clearly aligned with an Administration priority” will express that alignment in terms of USACE, Army, or DoD organizational goals.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW ETP Memo, Att. 1, para. 2.e. The intent is to avoid unnecessary politicization of DPMAP elements while still allowing management plenty of room to comply with the requirements.
Proposal 8:
In the event that a Higher Level Reviewer (HLR) of LRC/LRP/SPD BUEs believes that a BUE’s performance warrants a review by the Calibration Official(s) (CO) for increasing to an Outstanding level; the HLR shall make a calibration recommendation and fill out relevant portions of the Army Calibration Worksheet, and shall submit the employee’s file for inclusion in the LRC/LRP/SPD BUE rating population calibration.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW ETP Memo, Att. 1, para. 2.j. and USACE IG Memo, para. 5(c-d). Further, the Union’s intent is to address instances where the HLR may not feel confident in overriding the Rating Official, but does feel it is worth calibration.
Proposal 9:
In the event that the CO(s) determine that the distribution of Outstanding ratings within the LRC/LRP/SPD BUE rating population requires adjustment or revision of ratings to ensure that similar levels of performance receive similar ratings across work units or divisions; the CO(s) shall ensure that all BUEs in any anomalously-low work unit or division shall be submitted for calibration.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW IG Memo, fourth paragraph; and a §7106(b)(3) appropriate arrangement for adversely affected employees—to ensure that BUEs in under-rated work units or divisions have an opportunity to have their ratings calibrated UP rather than defaulting to calibrating other work units or divisions DOWN to the anomalously low level.
Proposal 10:
Preliminary ratings for LRC/LRP/SPD BUEs will be based solely on the performance elements and standards established in the performance plan, the employee’s self-assessment, and the Rating Official’s (RO) observations of the employee’s performance during the rating cycle. Observations made by Guest Raters or Guest Reviewers during the rating cycle may be adopted by the RO if documented in the DPMAP system by the Guest Rater or Guest Reviewer.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW IG Memo, Att. 1, para. 3.b.1. The intent is to adopt and clarify the Agency IG language.
Proposal 11:
Written records pertaining to any LRC/LRP/SPD BUE generated by the RO, HLR, and CO or their designees shall be produced to the affected BUE and/or their Representative when the performance of the BUE is cited in any disciplinary action or performance-based adverse action and the materials relied upon are requested; or when an employee requests the records pursuant to the Privacy Act. The Agency shall not redact the preliminary rating or the name of the official who generated the document when producing such records to the employee or their Representative.
This proposal is a §7106(b)(2) procedure for implementing the DoW IG Memo, para. 5, third bullet. This proposal ensures the transparency of the system and ensures due process is maintained.
We’ll let everyone know how the bosses respond. If past is prelude, they’ll try to fight us on everything, and it’ll wind up in a pile of FLRA cases that this Administration is refusing to process. The good news is, if that happens, the forced distribution will also be indefinitely delayed.
Leave a Reply